Tough consultations: Breaking bad news
Published: 09 May 2016
Female patient in her 50s, a smoker, has had a suspicious chest X-ray, which you need to discuss with her. Her symptoms are compatible with a lung cancer diagnosis.
Dr Trevor Thompson
Before meeting the patient, study her record. Find out the context of the consultation: you need to know if the possibility of cancer was discussed before the referral (which colleagues will certainly have noted).
When the patient arrives, discuss the results and check out her expectations. Be sensitive, but direct: ‘the X-ray shows changes that could mean that you have cancer’. You can show the patient the report and even print it out for her to take away, as some patients stop listening after they hear the word ‘cancer’.
You may find that the diagnosis isn’t quite as much as a surprise as one might expect. As a smoker, she will almost certainly have had suspicions. The issue of her current smoking is not something to address now – the last thing she needs is a reminder that she has inflicted this terrible predicament on herself. If she asks, ‘was it the smoking?’ then tell her most people with lung cancer are smokers, but that you can have lung cancer without it.
Sometimes people react very badly and become speechless and it becomes impossible to continue the consultation in a meaningful way. When this happens, we hope they have someone with them in the consulting room or in the waiting room. If not, insist that they take a seat, wait for a friend to arrive, and accept some tea and TLC from the reception staff.
In every case, try to dispense hope along with the bad news: even in the worst of scenarios there is always hope. For instance, say that there is still a possibility that the shadow on the X-ray is caused by an infection and not a cancer.
Dr Trevor Thompson is a GP and reader in health education, University of Bristol
Dr Matt Burkes
Bring the patient in for a face-to-face consultation and either put aside extra time or have it at the end of your surgery.
There is no perfect way to deliver bad news, but with every patient strive for ‘sensitive honesty’. Be aware of the shock or upset you are causing but be clear about your suspicions.
In this case, the diagnosis is not guaranteed, but be careful not to fall into the common trap of providing false reassurance. A warning shot can be helpful: for example, ‘The X-ray has some features that are worrying and I wanted to see you face to face to discuss this.’
Sometimes patients take the initiative from here and ask you directly what is going on. Other patients may be oblivious to the potential diagnosis, or in denial. Discuss the results in easily digestible chunks. Avoid jargon. Outline the findings and your fears.
Check that you are being understood; if not, go back and try an alternative way of explaining.
Acknowledge any distress, grief and fear. Reactions may surprise you: some patients already suspect the diagnosis; some may be angry with either themselves or with you and the medical profession if they feel the diagnosis should have been made earlier. Some patients are initially calm but break down afterwards. Check if they are okay to get home or if they would rather you called someone on their behalf. You could offer to discuss things with the patient’s loved ones if she would find this useful.
Outline the onward steps in your patient’s diagnostic journey: in this case a two-week referral to the lung team and CT scan and maybe a blood test. Advise the patient that she is welcome to schedule a review appointment with you. Discussions about quitting smoking should not form part of this initial consultation – address them, if required, at a follow-up appointment.
Dr Matt Burkes is a GP in Chichester, West Sussex
An elderly patient in her 80s has advanced cancer. She is now stopping treatment, and you have a consultation with her to discuss end-of-life care.
Dr Liz Moulton
Before the consultation, go through the patient’s records and think about the wider picture. What do you know about the family, and are others involved (a district nurse, palliative care team)? Ensure you have enough time for the consultation.
Consider visiting the patient at home – the advantages being that she is on ‘home territory’, you can get a sense of the practicalities (stairs and bathrooms), interruptions are less likely and it is easier to take your time.
To start the consultation, choose an open question and follow the patient’s lead. Asking: ‘How are you doing?’ or ‘How have things been lately?’, allows the patient to talk. If she denies problems, discuss recent hospital visits and what was said. You may, in rare cases, need to check that the patient knows treatment is being stopped.
How far you can get today will depend on the patient – be sensitive and responsive throughout, giving information in bite-sized amounts and trying to be sure that the patient has understood what is being said. Honesty is important but it is crucial not to take away hope.
Three key topics to cover – perhaps over several consultations - are preferred place of dying, symptom management, and who to contact out of hours. A DNACPR will need to be discussed as soon as reasonably possible but not necessarily straight away.
If a carer (for instance, her husband or daughter) is present, include them in the consultation (‘What do you think?’; ‘Anything to add?’). Remind them that you are there for them too.
End by arranging the date of the next consultation, and asking the patient to undertake specific tasks to prepare, for example, ‘I’ll come to see you again on Tuesday. You may well have questions: make a list and we can go through them.’
Dr Liz Moulton MBE is a freelance GP and consultations skills teacher in West Yorkshire. Her book The Naked Consultation is now on its second edition
Dr Mohammed Saqib Anwar
Preparation is key. Think carefully about where and when this conversation should take place and who else may need to be present. This would very much depend on the individual patient, her physical status and who she wanted to be around. It is important to ensure that family members and loved ones, where agreed, are able to be involved in key decisions and considerations but remain mindful of the need to protect the patient’s confidentiality and dignity throughout.
Prior to meeting, spend some time thinking about the key areas that need to be covered, such as ascertaining the patient’s views on ceilings of treatment, resuscitation orders, advanced decisions to refuse treatments and preferred place of care at the end of her life.
Most CCGs have now produced a template care plan that can aid doctors and ensure they cover all relevant aspects, which you could use. That said, this should be used with caution and my advice to all doctors is to not be bound by them and not to turn it into a tick-box exercise. The commonest deficiency is where doctors get caught up in completing the paperwork.
As for the actual conversation, it is important that you involve the patient and her family in as much of this as possible. Sensitively ask open questions that will help you understand their views on the key areas. Make sure you cover what is important to them. This helps with creating a sense of ownership of the plan and can help immensely with managing of expectations of all concerned.
Remember that discussions of this nature need to be measured and paced appropriately, so they do not have be done in one sitting. If the situation allows, it is better to give people time to think, absorb and reflect on the discussions before making any firm decisions.
Dr Mohammed Saqib Anwar is a GP partner in Oadby, Leicestershire